Gwyneth Paltrow’s country-music debut at the CMA’s helped the award show land on the list.  The CMA Awards won its time slot the night they aired in November.  A Christmas themed episode and Amber Tamblyn’s first appearance as a new member of the House team were also among the most checked-in shows on this year.  Here’s the complete top 10 list:

10. CSI: Miami, "Manhunt"

9. Gossip Girl , "War at the Roses"

8. The Office, "The Sting"

7. The Mentalist, "Red Moon"

6. Vampire Diaries, "Masquerade"

5. Supernatural, "Appointment in Samarra"

4. Criminal Minds, "Devil's Night"

2. House, "Office Politics"

1. NCIS, "False Witness"