Churches For Sale + Prices Around Western New York

It is crazy how many churches are closing in Western New York. This week 180 priests met for a meeting that would announce around 100 churches to merge or close in the Western New York area. The Catholic Diocese of Buffalo announced that  there would be a “34% reduction in parishes. 38% reduction in worship spaces.”

The The Catholic Diocese of Buffalo announced there would be someone to come in and help set fair prices on their buildings and churches. In the meantime, here are some churches that are already on the market that may or not have been a part of the Diocese:

• 1601 Cleveland Ave Niagara Falls, NY 14305 $150,000
• 4229 Delaware Ave Tonawanda, NY 14150 $275,000
• 11 Doat St, 24 Rustic & 1609 Genesee St $950,000
• 760 Ellicott St Buffalo, NY 14203 $1,400,000
• 711 Knox Rd East Aurora, NY 14052 $5,300,000

Here are all of the parishes and locations that are closing or merging in Western New York:

• St. Rose of Lima, Buffalo
• All Saints, Buffalo
• Holy Spirit, Buffalo
• Holy Cross, Buffalo
• St. Michael, Buffalo
• Coronation of the Bl. Virgin Mary, Buffalo
• St. John Kanty, Buffalo
• St. Thomas Aquinas, Buffalo
• St. Ambrose or St. Martin of Tours, Buffalo
• St. Bernard, Buffalo

• Good Shepherd, Clarence
• St. Aloysius Gonzaga, Cheektowaga
• Infant of Prague, Cheektowaga
• St. Andrew, Kenmore
• Blessed Sacrament, Tonawanda
• St. Francis of Assisi, Tonawanda
• St. Jude the Apostle, North Tonawanda
• St. Pius X, Getzville
• St. John Vianney, Orchard Park
• St. John XXIII, West Seneca

• St. Josaphat, Cheektowaga
• Queen of Martyrs, Cheektowaga
• St. Martha, Depew
• St. Mother Teresa of Calcutta, Depew
• St. Anthony, Lackawanna
• Our Mother of Good Counsel, Blasdell
• Our Lady of Bistrica, Lackawanna
• St. Francis of Assisi, Hamburg
• St. Anthony, Farnham

• All Saints, St. Patrick site, Lockport
• All Saints, St. Joseph site, Lockport
• St. Brendan on the Lake, Wilson site
• Holy Trinity, Middleport site
• St. Mark, Kendall
• Former Lyndonville property, rectory
• St. Raphael, Niagara Falls
• St. John de LaSalle, Niagara Falls
• Divine Mercy, Niagara Falls

• Our Lady of Mount Carmel, Forestville site
• St. Joseph, Fredonia
• St. Anthony, Fredonia (Feb. 15, 2026)
• Blessed Mary Angela, St. Hyacinth site, Dunkirk
  (Feb. 15, 2026)
• Blessed Mary Angela, St. Hedwig site, Dunkirk
• Holy Apostles Peter and Paul, SS. Peter and Paul
  site, Jamestown
• Sacred Heart, Panama site
• St. James, Frewsburg site
• Our Lady of Loretto, Falconer
• St. Dominic, Brocton site
• Christ Our Hope, Sherman site
• Holy Spirit, North Collins
• St. Mary, Cattaraugus