This Is The Best Cinnamon Roll In Western New York

This is your sign to treat yourself to one of Western New York’s favorite sweets. 

There’s nothing like locally baked goods at one of our favorite bakeries, and while they all taste homemade with love, there are some bakeries that are known for one sweet treat over the others.

With October 4 being Cinnamon Roll Day, we thought it was time to just clear the air for where to find the best cinnamon roll in town. 

We took a poll on our Facebook page, and the responses confirmed what we already knew: there are a lot of locally owned bakeries that make delicious cinnamon rolls. 

While one place came out on top, there was another place that was a close second for delicious cinnamon rolls, and it’s safe to say that both of these places are loved by Western New Yorkers.

The top two places for cinnamon rolls are:

Kaylena Marie’s Bakery, and…

Aunt Millie’s Family Restaurant & Bakery.

Kaylena Marie’s Bakery is located on Orchard Park Rd in Buffalo, and Aunt Millie’s is located in Irving. 

And if those locations are a little too far out of the way for you, you can still snag a delicious cinnamon roll from these honorable mentions:

• Mardee’s in Clarence Center

• McDuffies Bakery in Clarence

• The Garage Bar & Restaurant on Hertel Ave.

• Sweet Pea Bakery in Hamburg

• The No B S Bakery in Blasdell 

  • They have Gluten Free cinnamon rolls!

• Demetri's On the Lake in Dunkirk, NY

• Laports Pine St Restaurant in Lockport, NY

• Mel’s Place in Chaffee, NY

• Frosted Fairytale Bake Shop in Angola

• Knead the Dough in Ransomville, NY

October 4th is National Cinnamon Roll Day, so if you get a chance, stop by one of your favorite local bakeries in Western New York! :)